JavaScript is turned off in your web browser. Many features of this website depend on you having Javascript turned on, please enable it in your browser settings.

Main » Editorial, Featured Articles

Illusory Superiority

By Michael Gugel - April 16th, 2010

Your not as good as you think you areI think I’m a better driver than average. 93% of people think they’re a better driver than average too. Statistically, 50% of people are above average and 50% are below average. I guess most of us are pretty delusional when it comes to our driving ability.

The tendency for people to overrate their skills is called illusory superiority. It happens in all kinds of situations –including the self-assessment of intelligence, memory, job performance, popularity, happiness and poker skill.

Incompetent players overestimate their skill and fail to recognize the skill of other players. Ironically, good players tend to underrate their skill. As Bertrand Russell put it, “the trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt.”

Illusory superiority is also one of the main reasons fish continue to play despite losing a significant amount of money. They’ve deluded themselves into thinking they’re good and just rationalize away their losses. They blame bad luck, the government, rigged poker rooms, etc.

It’s important to remember that we were all fish when we started playing poker – we were all below average. The players that recognized their weaknesses and worked hard at correcting them tended to rise to the top. If you’re susceptible to tilt, learn how to correct it. If you lose money in 3bet pots, learn how to correct it. If you can’t put a player on a hand, learn how to correct it. Understanding and working on your weaknesses is what will make you a great poker player. You can only correct something when you know it’s a problem.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon

Tags:

75 Responses to “Illusory Superiority”

  1. MrThomasMoyes avatar MrThomasMoyes says:

    The people nitpicking this article are just demonstrating how true it actually is, I’m sure everybody knows how basic math works, stop pretending to be smarter than everyone else.

  2. JOHNNIEPUNAWNY avatar JOHNNIEPUNAWNY says:

    I wouldn’t take anything Gugel has to say toooooo seriously.

  3. jordyleon avatar jordyleon says:

    well…people knows how basic math works, but complex? Poker its not just maths…lots of X on diferent situations. btw, real poker its not on line poker =) and real % its not on line =)

  4. giyom avatar giyom says:

    The average IQ of people posting on this site is below average.

  5. giyom avatar giyom says:

    Great article btw. “the trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt.” I love it.

  6. pokerxpro avatar pokerxpro says:

    Please remove this article from your site.

    The last thing we need is the few remaining fish hearing this non sense

  7. jooztvdberg avatar jooztvdberg says:

    pokerxpro says:
    April 18, 2010 at 7:51 am
    Please remove this article from your site.

    The last thing we need is the few remaining fish hearing this non sense

    DUDE this article is about people like u!! so lol

  8. superdonk avatar superdonk says:

    ‘Statistically, 50% of people are above average and 50% are below average.’ Buddy, you failed in statistic…

  9. suitedeights avatar suitedeights says:

    Don’t encourage the fish to get better please.

  10. Kole avatar Kole says:

    He assumes standard normal distribution, where average(mean) and median are the same meaning that 50% will be over and 50% will be under the average. So “Buddy”, I guess you failed in statistics.

  11. bulletbox avatar bulletbox says:

    this is also called the Dunning–Kruger effect, there is a big wiki article on it as well as all the cognitive biases very useful stuff

  12. silentreaper avatar silentreaper says:

    It is interesting that you picked driving a car to compare to poker. In poker it is generally clear cut who is above average and below average, judging by results over time. (I understand that as time goes on a player can change/get better or worse, thrusting their results way out the window, but we’ll use results as a marker)

    Driving has a completely different scale of measurement. The Dunning-Kruger effect is intriguing, however it is possible that 93% of people claim to be a better driver than others because a vast majority of people see being a good driver as different things.

    My personal opinion: I drive faster than most people and tend to weave in and out of traffic more frequently than other people, however I am much more alert and maintain better control of my car than “the average driver.” I can also flawlessly drive a manual transmission, something that very few people under the age of 35 (in america) are capable of doing, if they had ever even tried.

    Now Susie Joe sees me driving, as she maintains a steady 5 mph under the speed limit, and thinks to herself what a terrible driver. This type of person sees themselves as the best driver because they are “safe,” however in many instances being the slowest driver on the road could be the most dangerous.

    Then there is Jasper, who thinks hes the best because he can send text messages while holding a conversation on the phone and eating a foot long sub. Well, we all know how most people feel about Jasper.

    Then there are the all around drivers who follow the flow of traffic and don’t make many lane changes (perhaps the safest drivers). After breaking that down, I think its safe to say that between these mindsets you would come very close to 93% of the population believing they are a better driver, for different reasons. Who are the better-than-average drivers? I would say people like myself ( :-0 ) and people who follow the flow of traffic, but it would be interesting to hear what a professional on that topic would have to say.

  13. Goldfish1983 avatar Goldfish1983 says:

    Thanks Kole,

    Good advice. Yeah I am going to try and be more patient overall, because patience is a big part of my game that I have to work on.

    No limit seems like a fun game, like 99% of the poker I watch on television is no limit; however it is quite a transition from limit to no limit. I think all forms of poker have their pros and cons. My friend tried no limit and ran really bad, losing like 700 hundred bucks really quick with set over set and flopped two pair and got counterfitted on the river by a better two pair.

    Omaha seems like a wild game, cause there are so many hand possibilities!

    Yeah poker is a very complicated game! You can always learn something new everyday!

  14. jiggga avatar jiggga says:

    Please stop helping fish

  15. Sharkament avatar Sharkament says:

    Please remove this article from your site.

    The last thing we need is the few remaining fish hearing this non sense

  16. Sharkament avatar Sharkament says:

    PTR is seriously one of the main reasons online poker will dry up even more.. You guys are awesome.. for fuck sake.

  17. Kole avatar Kole says:

    You guys really believe that because of this post all of a sudden there will be no more donks at the tables? Like there weren’t dozens of books and thousands of posts written about how to get better in poker already.

  18. CERON1 avatar CERON1 says:

    i read this took it on board and im still a spewtard aggrodonk busting to any of you everyday

  19. roadrunnerXD avatar roadrunnerXD says:

    Lol DonKaMenTs

  20. JOKER_WALKER avatar JOKER_WALKER says:

    A lot of people are not willing to dedicate their time and energy to develop poker skills – it is possible to win hands by simple stupid, and fancy looking play (unlike in chess)- so fish always remain on the field.

  21. rubikkkk avatar rubikkkk says:

    great!

  22. barten avatar barten says:

    did no one else see the irony in this

    giyom says:
    April 18, 2010 at 7:17 am
    The average IQ of people posting on this site is below average.

    giyom says:
    April 18, 2010 at 7:24 am
    Great article btw. “the trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt.” I love it.

  23. Grafter avatar Grafter says:

    I seem to be the only one to notice the flaw written by the author…

    “93% of people think they’re a better driver than average too. Statistically, 50% of people are above average and 50% are below average. I guess most of us are pretty delusional when it comes to our driving ability.”

    Actually, it is the minority that are delusional (93%-50%=43%). 43% is less than half and therefore a minority that are delusional.

    And to all those wanting this be deleted/removed, there is no chance this article will dry up the supply of fish…

  24. [...] că răceala mi-a trecut, m-am decis ca să mai postez ceva aici. Este un articol luat de pe pokertableratings.com care se aplică nu numai acestui joc, ci şi în viaţă. Cred că sunt un şofer mai bun [...]

  25. jobposting-tech…

    [...]Illusory Superiority | PokerTableRatings.com Blog[...]…

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Latest News
» Hands Tracked:
18,715,417,873
» Tables Watched:
6,557
By Lee Murphy 2 weeks ago
By Lee Murphy 3 weeks ago
By Lee Murphy 1 month ago
PTR_Dameon: PartyPoker Challenge II Winners Announced ...
3 months ago
PTR Wall
Isildur1 is up $19,922 today
11 minutes ago
tormont commented on 7bars77
1 hour ago ·More info
labersack commented on ratedr7
1 hour ago ·More info
Astolfo commented on ljstewart
1 hour ago ·More info
Madagenda won a $11,999 pot
4 hours ago ·More info
Madagenda won a $10,999 pot with 2Spade2Heart
4 hours ago ·More info
sanssone won a $11,999 pot with 2Diamond2Spade
4 hours ago ·More info